What is the controversy behind Louisiana’s new surgical castration law? (2024)

Baton Rouge, Louisiana – Louisiana has become the first state in the United States to impose surgical castration as a criminal punishment.

The new law, which came into effect on Thursday, allows the court to order surgical castration — the removal of a man’s testes or a woman’s ovaries — as punishment for adults convicted of first or second-degree aggravated rape in cases involving child victims under 13.

Keep reading

list of 3 items

list 1 of 3

Salt in paradise: What a Louisiana crabber is losing to saltwater intrusion

list 2 of 3

In the US South, pro-Palestinians face crackdown on campus and in streets

list 3 of 3

Mike Johnson elected US House speaker, ending weeks of gridlock

end of list

Some states already impose chemical castration, a reversible procedure, as punishment. But only Louisiana mandates surgical castration.

The measure comes amidst a spate of “tough-on-crime” legislation passed this year by Louisiana’s conservative supermajority and signed into law by Republican Governor Jeff Landry, who took office in January.

Critics, however, warn that such laws are radically punitive and ultimately ineffective in preventing crimes.

Among those outspoken against the law is George Annas, the director of Boston University’s Center for Health Law, Ethics and Human Rights. He described the measure as “anti-medicine” and unconstitutional: “It just makes no sense.”

What is the controversy behind Louisiana’s new surgical castration law? (1)

Legal challenges anticipated

Louisiana and several other states, including California and Florida, already have laws that impose chemical castration for certain sex crimes.

That procedure usually entails injections of Depo Provera, a birth control medication that temporarily lowers testosterone in both men and women.

Even that procedure has its detractors, though. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has never approved the drug for the treatment of sex offenders, and critics decry putting physicians in the position of meting out punishments for the criminal justice system.

Such laws have already been repealed in Oregon and Georgia and ruled unconstitutional in South Carolina.

But unlike chemical castration, surgical castration is permanent. Lawyers like Annas have raised questions about whether surgical castration violates the US Constitution’s prohibition against “cruel and unusual punishment”.

Annas warns the law is also unconstitutional as it denies the right to reproduce and the right to bodily integrity. Under Louisiana’s new law, an offender can refuse the procedure, but if they do, they would instead receive an additional three- to five-year prison sentence.

“If you can get out of jail by volunteering your testicles,” Annas said, “that’s coercive.”

He believes the law will not survive the inevitable court challenges from rights groups.

“It is blatantly unconstitutional,” said Annas. “There is no way any judge in this country, even in Louisiana, would find this to be a valid punishment.”

Giacomo Castrogiovanni, a lawyer who administers the reentry programme at Loyola University’s Law Clinic, described the new law as “very aggressive” and agrees it will face legal challenges.

“I expect that is going to be a really strong challenge,” said Castrogiovanni — but he is less certain than Annas that it will be successful in striking down the law. “I really don’t know what’s going to come of that. It’ll be interesting.”

What is the controversy behind Louisiana’s new surgical castration law? (2)

Questions of efficacy

But beyond its legal merits, the surgical castration law has raised scrutiny about its efficacy in combatting sex crimes.

Annas argued that the law would simply be ineffective. “It’s very hard to find a physician who thinks this makes any medical sense,” he said.

The urge to commit sexual violence, he explained, “is not necessarily related to the amount of testosterone you have”.

Dr Katrina Sifferd, a criminal justice researcher and former legal analyst for the National Institute of Justice, likewise expressed scepticism. “Sometimes there are claims that this is going to either rehabilitate, deter or incapacitate,” she said. “And it looks like that isn’t the case.”

Sifferd explained that people who commit sex crimes against children do so for many different reasons: “trauma, aggression, a need for love — all sorts of things” that castration wouldn’t address.

And castration doesn’t necessarily dampen sexual urges or prevent erections.

“There’s no scientific evidence that this is going to ‘work’ to save anybody. And it’s certainly not going to cure the person of being a paedophile,” Annas said.

For her part, Sifferd said she understands the reluctance to protect the rights of people who have committed grave crimes against children.

But she stressed that corporal — or physical — punishment is not meant to be part of the US criminal legal system.

“The criminal justice system has to maintain its moral authority. And every punishment that’s applied has to be justified,” she said. “Otherwise, it’s a real slippery slope in what we allow the state to do.”

What is the controversy behind Louisiana’s new surgical castration law? (3)

A punitive approach

The new law highlights longstanding concerns about the punitive nature of Louisiana’s criminal justice system.

Louisiana has been called the “prison capital of the world”. It has the highest incarceration rate of any state in a country that already tops all other democracies for the proportion of people behind bars.

Out of every 100,000 people in Louisiana, approximately 1,067 people are locked up in jails, prisons and detention centres.

Louisiana’s surgical castration law comes into effect as part of a spate of legislation that creates even more crimes to prosecute.

Among the laws taking effect on Thursday is a measure that makes it a crime to remain within 7.6 metres — or 25 feet — of a police officer after being warned to retreat.

Another law will make the possession of unprescribed abortion medication punishable by up to five years behind bars. Another eliminates parole.

The experts who spoke with Al Jazeera largely interpreted the new castration law as a Republican effort.

Castrogiovanni, the lawyer, described it as “a new implementation of conservative policies”, which tend to reflect more punitive approaches to addressing crime. He pointed out that, until recently, Louisiana had a Democratic governor who could veto some of the more controversial right-wing bills.

However, the surgical castration law passed by wide margins in both chambers of the state legislature. In the state House, it sailed through by a vote of 74 to 24, and in the Senate, it earned 29 votes, easily defeating the nine “nays”.

Democrats were among its supporters. In fact, two authored the bill.

What is the controversy behind Louisiana’s new surgical castration law? (4)

A personal battle

One of the co-authors was state Representative Delisha Boyd, who spent the same legislative session unsuccessfully championing bills that represent more traditional Democratic priorities: protecting gay rights and reproductive access, for instance.

She even drew on her own experiences to argue that Louisiana’s abortion ban should include exceptions for rape and incest.

Her mother, Boyd testified to the Louisiana legislature, had been raped as a minor. She became pregnant with Boyd when she was only 15, and Boyd testified that the trauma of both the rape and forced pregnancy contributed to her mother’s death before age 30.

That bill, however, failed.

In an interview with Al Jazeera, Boyd reflected on the irony: Louisiana doctors may now perform a medical procedure as punishment for rape, but those same doctors could be arrested for providing medical care to a rape survivor.

“I’m disgusted by that,” said Boyd. She finds it hypocritical that abortion opponents say they want to protect children but also “want to keep [the child rape victim] with a whole other human being in her body, ignoring how it’s not even her choice to have this baby”.

“I’m here because my mother experienced that,” she added.

That personal history, Boyd explained, is part of why she has become an advocate for survivors of sexual violence.

Boyd stridently defends the surgical castration law. She considers some of its critics apologists for child sex offenders.

“I am offended by anyone who has actually read this bill and still wants to defend the rapist,” she said.

And she doubts the penalty will be imposed often. She pointed out that chemical castration, already a penalty in Louisiana, has been imposed just a handful of times in the last 20 years.

But Boyd believes that, if the surgical castration law stops even one person, it will be worth it.

Sifferd, however, called that rationale “a really dangerous argument” to make. In her opinion, extreme punishments risk causing greater societal harm.

“Imagine if we applied this to other sorts of crimes, right? We apply a $10,000 fine for speeding, in case it stops even one person from speeding, and so we’re going to apply it to everybody. It’s unjustified,” Sifferd said.

Sifferd also noted that there’s consistent evidence showing that imposing harsher penalties is not an effective crime deterrent.

What is the controversy behind Louisiana’s new surgical castration law? (5)

Focusing on survivors

Some advocates also argue that the focus on punishment diverts attention away from the survivors themselves.

The Committee for Children, a nonprofit, wrote a policy briefing explaining that “the vast majority of government funding for child abuse” goes to “convicting and managing the perpetrator” rather than preventing the abuse in the first place.

This could include programmes to support survivors or alleviate risk factors. Studies have indicated that rates of sexual violence are linked to gender and economic inequality.

And Louisiana has the second-highest poverty rate in the US, not to mention one of the country’s highest maternal mortality rates.

A recent study from Tulane University in New Orleans found that 41 percent of respondents reported experiencing sexual violence during their lifetime.

Boyd said this points to a bigger issue: “Women and children are endangered species in this state.”

What is the controversy behind Louisiana’s new surgical castration law? (2024)

FAQs

What is the controversy behind Louisiana’s new surgical castration law? ›

Proponents of the Louisiana law, including Democratic Sen. Regina Barrow, who authored it, hope the new possible punishment will deter people from committing such heinous crimes against children. Opponents argue that it is cruel and unusual punishment. Louisiana has 2,224 people in prison for such crimes.

What is the argument against chemical castration? ›

Chemical castration changes some of the desires of the individuals who use it. So, unless an individual has consented (waived their right), the chemical castration of that individual violates his right against others' interference with his thoughts and desires.

What is the problem with chemical castration? ›

These drugs can also cause depression, hot flashes, infertility and anemia, aside from cardiovascular diseases and osteoporosis. The risk of side effects caused by chemical castration drugs can increase depending on the length of time under which they are administered.

What does chemical castration do to a man? ›

Chemical castration in medical applications is highly effective and is not permanent. Its long-term use, however, is associated with anemia, depression, fatigue, heart disease, hot flashes, loss of libido, osteoporosis, and weight gain. Chemical castration in men may result in gynecomastia (enlargement of the breasts).

What exactly is surgical castration? ›

(SER-jih-kul kas-TRAY-shun) Surgical removal of the testicles (orchiectomy) or ovaries (oophorectomy) to stop the production of sex hormones. Decreasing the levels of hormones may stop the growth of certain cancers.

Is castration legal in Louisiana? ›

Louisiana is now the first state to allow surgical castration to be used as a punishment for sex crimes under a new law signed by Republican Gov. Jeff Landry. This law, which will go into effect Aug. 1, allows judges to order people found guilty of certain sex crimes against minors to undergo surgical castration.

Can a castrated man still get hard? ›

He can still have an erection. In general, castrated men experience a much-diminished sex drive, because their bodies have very low levels of the male hormone testosterone. This lowers the frequency, strength, and duration of erections, and can cause hot flashes, vertigo, loss of body hair, and breast growth.

What happens to a man after castration? ›

Castration after puberty, turning men into eunuchs, diminishes or completely eliminates the sex drive. Muscle mass, physical strength, and body hair are all typically reduced, and eunuchs are usually beardless.

Does chemical castration last? ›

Chemical castration lasts as long as you continue to take the drugs. Once you stop taking them, hormone production returns to normal. The effects are generally reversible. But if you've been taking the medications for a long time, some side effects may continue.

What states have castration laws? ›

A handful of states, including Louisiana, California, Florida and Texas, have laws allowing for chemical castration for those guilty of certain sex crimes. In some of those states, offenders can opt for the surgical procedure if they prefer.

Can a woman be chemically castrated? ›

Chemical castration has been rarely used in females too. Lowering the testosterone levels in females can lead to lowering of their sex drive. Such castration will also cause shrinkage of breasts and enlargements of nipples.

What is castration for a woman? ›

It involves removing and damaging healthy and normal female genital tissue, and it interferes with the natural functions of girls' and women's bodies. Although all forms of FGM are associated with increased risk of health complications, the risk is greater with more severe forms of FGM.

Does castration change a man's voice? ›

From the late 16th century, castration was carried out in Italy to preserve the unbroken male voice into adult life, but the high pitch was accompanied by fully grown resonating chambers and a large thoracic capacity, giving rise to the unique voice of the castrato.

Are there eunuchs today? ›

In reality, there are more castrated men alive today that at any other point in history. As many as 600,000 men in North America are living as eunuchs for medical reasons. The vast majority are afflicted with prostate cancer.

What is the new surgical law in Louisiana? ›

The new law, which came into effect on Thursday, allows the court to order surgical castration — the removal of a man's testes or a woman's ovaries — as punishment for adults convicted of first or second-degree aggravated rape in cases involving child victims under 13.

Is a vasectomy the same as a surgical castration? ›

Castration involves the complete removal of the testes, while vasectomy targets the vas deferens, leaving the testicles intact. This makes vasectomy a less invasive and more appealing option for males seeking sterilisation.

What are the pros and cons of chemical castration? ›

Pros and Cons of Chemical Castration
Pros of Chemical CastrationCons of Chemical Castration
Allows for future breeding as it is reversible.Less immediate compared to surgical castration; takes time to become effective.
4 more rows
Nov 21, 2023

What is the downside of castration? ›

Among the disadvantages of castration are depression, impotence, sterility, obesity, osteoporosis, hot flashes, and genital modification.

Can chemical castration cause aggression? ›

In very rare cases (<0.01%), a transient behavioural change has been reported with the development of aggression. Surgical or medical castration might have unexpected consequences (i.e. improvement or worsening) on aggressive behaviour.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Ouida Strosin DO

Last Updated:

Views: 6322

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (76 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ouida Strosin DO

Birthday: 1995-04-27

Address: Suite 927 930 Kilback Radial, Candidaville, TN 87795

Phone: +8561498978366

Job: Legacy Manufacturing Specialist

Hobby: Singing, Mountain biking, Water sports, Water sports, Taxidermy, Polo, Pet

Introduction: My name is Ouida Strosin DO, I am a precious, combative, spotless, modern, spotless, beautiful, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.